|
The NSM Model 50, despite its conventional appearance,
is not just another conventional column loudspeaker. The goal
of its designers was to produce a "compact acoustic suspension
system with the bass response of a subwoofer, and the imaging
and soundstaging of a minimonitor."
To achieve those goals, they located its single 6/2-inch bass
driver in a separate sealed subenclosure at the bottom of the
cabinet, with heavy bracing to ensure rigidity and damped with
open-cell foam and Dacron. At the top of the cabinet they placed
another 6l/2 inch cone driver to handle the midbass and midrange
frequencies. NSM does not indicate the effective crossover frequency
between these drivers, or to the single 1-inch soft-dome tweeter
located midway between the two cone speakers.
NSM stresses the Model 50's imaging characteristics, which are
said to be due in part to its minimum-phase crossover network
and careful matching of the drivers and crossover component values
in each pair of speakers. The Model 50 is sold only in pairs,
bearing identical numbers and distinguished by their "A"
and "B" designations. The specific component values
used in each Pair of speakers are recorded on the production
schedule, so that the speakers can readily be restored to their
original matched performance in the event of damage. Although
NSM states that it "breaks in" drivers and matches
them before assembly, the owner's manual recommends that the
speakers be "broken in" for 200 hours at low to moderate
volume to insure the best possible performance.
The upper two-thirds of the front panel is covered by a removable
black cloth grille. Near the bottom of the rear panel are two
pairs of recessed, gold-plated binding posts, normally joined
by gold-plated straps. With the straps removed, the system can
be biwired or biamplified.
The Model 50's frequency response is rated as a "room response"
of the pair of speakers under specific conditions that do not
include the room dimensions; the rating cannot be correlated
with any measurements we might be able to make. The sensitivity
of each speaker is given as relatively low 85 dB sound-pressure
level (SPL) on the tweeter axis at 1 meter with a 1 watt input
(presumably the standard 2.83 volts). Unconventionally, the manufacturer
gives three impedance ratings: minimum 4 ohms, rated 8 ohms,
and "nominal" 16 ohms.
NSM recommends that the
speakers be fitted with the supplied spiked feet and, if possible,
biwired. Neither was practical for our measurements and listening
tests. We did |
place them about 3 feet from the walls and 8 feet apart, however,
essentially as recommended.
The Model 50's measured
sensitivity was 85 dB, exactly as rated. The room response above
a few hundred Hertz was very uniform and smooth, with a variation
of only +2.5 dB from 300 Hz to 20 kHz. When we measured the quasi-anechoic
responses of the two cone drivers, with close microphone spacing,
we found that the woofer (lower driver) output reached its maximum
at 100 Hz, falling at 12 dB per octave below about 70 Hz and
at 6 dB per octave from 100 Hz to 300 Hz. The upper driver (midrange)
had a similar response below 100 Hz (about 3 dB lower in level
than the lower one), but did not drop off as rapidly at higher
frequencies and delivered several times as much power above 500
Hz as did the lower driver. Both drivers appeared to cut off
above 3 kHz.
Splicing the woofer curves to the room response to create a composite
response was difficult. A reasonable match existed in the range
of 300 to 700 Hz, resulting in a composite curve flat within
+2.5 dB from 250 Hz to 20 kHz, rising about 6 dB from 250 to
100 Hz, and returning to its midrange level at 45 Hz. Even at
32 Hz, the output was only 6 or 7 dB below the average midrange
level, and (as listening confirmed) it was perfectly audible
and usable at that frequency.
Quasi-anechoic MLS frequency-response measurements at several
different distances from the speaker shared a number of common
characteristics. All showed a maximum output at 1.5 to 2 kHz,
dropping to a minimum at about 5 kHz, and returning to the 300Hz
level (the low-frequency limit of this measurement) at several
frequencies between 7 and 20 kHz. Despite these minor variations,
typical of most speakers in this sort of measurement,
the overall response varied a mere +3 dB from 300 Hz to 20 kHz,
confirming the room-response measurements.
The system's horizontal directivity was typical of a l-inch dome
tweeter. At 45 degrees off-axis, the output at 10 kHz fell 4
or 5 dB relative to the on-axis response, and the difference
increased to 12 dB at 15 kHz and 18 dB at 20 kHz. The Model 50's
group delay (an indicator of its phase linearity) was among the
lowest and most uniform we have measured to date, with a peak-to-peak
variation of less than 0.2 millisecond from a few hundred Hertz
to 20 kHz.
The Model 50's impedance curve was rather unusual (as suggested
by its unconventional manner of specification). Over most of
the audio range, from 1 to 20 kHz, the impedance ranged between
20 and 28 ohms. At lower frequencies it dropped |
steeply, to a minimum of
5 ohms at 120 Hz, climbing to a bass resonance of 11 ohms at
65 Hz and dropping to 4.8 ohms at 29 Hz.
We measured the woofer
distortion with a 5-volt input (corresponding to our 90-dB reference
level for this measurement). From 60 to 220 Hz, it was between
0.55 and 1 percent, rising at lower frequencies to 7.5 percent
at 40 Hz and 13 percent at 30 Hz. In the upper part of the woofer's
range, the distortion rose to 1.5 percent at 400 Hz and somewhat
more at higher frequencies. But it was the upper cone driver,
whose output was comparable to that of the lower driver up to
about 300 Hz, that dominated the system output above 400 Hz,
with a roughly constant distortion level of 1 percent from 300
Hz to 1 kHz and less than 2 percent up to 2.5 kHz, where our
measurement stopped.
Because of its high
average impedance, the Model 50 can probably handle the full
output of most amplifiers likely to be driving it. Our pulse
power tests resulted in the amplifier clipping (at about 330
watts) at 1 and 10 kHz before the speaker emitted any signs of
distress. Only at 100 Hz were we able to generate the rasping
sound of a cone reaching its excursion limits, which also required
an input of well over 300 watts (and left the speaker unscathed).
All of this suggests that the NSM Model 50 is a very good speaker,
which had been apparent from our first listening. How did it
sound? For one thing, it was unobtrusive, in the sense that we
were never particularly aware that the sound was emanating from
those black boxes, even when quite close to one of the speakers.
Its stereo imaging was excellent, as demonstrated by the way
it dealt with the imaging tests of the Chesky JD37 CD.
It is difficult, however, to describe the tonal characteristics
of a loudspeaker in terms that convey one person's reaction to
another person who has not heard it. I compared the NSM Model
50's to some other speakers of similar stature that happened
to be on hand, whose sound I had admired. I could get used to
either one (and like its sound very much), yet when switching
between them I found myself hearing properties of each that I
preferred at one moment or another, depending on the program
material.
I suspect that the NSM speakers were the more "accurate"
of the two (whatever that may mean), and that its spatial performance
was more realistic. I like sonically-unobtrusive speakers that
do not call attention to themselves yet give a believable impression
of a concert-hall performance. By those criteria, the NSM Model
50 is a great success. Hear it for yourself if you can. |